Photo: Just say

Tell Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Quebec Premier Jean Charest to stop propping up the asbestos industry (Credit: Daremoshiranai via Flickr).

By Lisa Gue, Environmental health policy analyst

Asbestos is hardly used in Canada anymore. In fact its use is severely restricted under Canada's Asbestos Products Regulations because it causes cancer. That Canada continues to produce asbestos for export and promote its use beyond our borders is a case of questionable ethics.

This sorry chapter in our history looked like it might finally close when Canada's last two asbestos mines, both in Québec, began to wind-down their operations. Jeffrey Mine largely suspended production in 2009, and the Lac d'Amiante mine announced it will close permanently on November 13, 2011.

But wait! Jeffrey Mine has come forward with a proposal to restart and expand production. To finance this revival — which would see 200,000 tonnes of asbestos produced a year, mainly for export to India — the mine has asked the Quebec government for a $58 million loan guarantee. Astonishingly, it seems the government is struggling to make up its mind whether to throw this toxic industry a lifeline.

The province was going to announce a decision in the summer, but didn't. The deadline was extended to October 31. That date has come and gone and now the government is saying it hopes to resolve the issue before Christmas.

Politicians are frequently required to grapple with tough decisions, but this just isn't one of them.

Should the government encourage production of a substance that causes cancer and is toxic when inhaled? NO.

Should Canada and Quebec be hawking a substance that is hardly used anymore here at home — because of health concerns — for export to countries like India? NO.

Should tax-payers be on the hook if the privately-owned mine (which is already under bankruptcy protection) is unable to repay its debts? NO.

The Government of Quebec should reject the proposed loan guarantee, stop propping up the asbestos industry and move onto other issues... such as strengthening the province's ban on lawn pesticides and investing in green energy, for example.

Meanwhile, the federal government should stop the hypocrisy and get behind international efforts to restrict trade in asbestos. Canada has repeatedly blocked the listing of chrysotile asbestos — the type mined here — under the Rotterdam Convention spurning the advice of health advocates like the Canadian Medical Association. Government MPs recently voted down an NDP motion to ban asbestos mining and exports.

Of course there are jobs at stake. Jeffrey Mine currently employs about 200 people, most of them part-time as the mine only operates sporadically. The Canadian Labour Congress, a strong advocate for banning asbestos, has called on governments to support workers' transition through investments in training and other assistance. That makes sense and in fact over the years the Government of Quebec has actively promoted economic diversification in the region of the mine.

Send a note to Quebec Premier Jean Charest and Prime Minister Harper asking them to pull the plug on exports of deadly Canadian asbestos to developing countries. Send a message now.

Download the David Suzuki Foundation's recent letter to Premier Jean Charest (PDF, French with English translation appended).

November 7, 2011

Read more

Post a comment


Feb 03, 2012
8:02 AM

I agree! Its good to have banned production in US, but they're still importing it! AND its still used worldwide

Nov 12, 2011
4:06 AM

On Nov. 11, 2011, our Family laid to rest a fine Canadian man, Clarry Armstrong, who was exposed in his Youth to Asbestos as a Carpenter in New Zealand. He had developed Lung Cancer, never smoked a day in his life, Asbestosis took away a kind, gentle Family man who contributed so much to Society and left us too soon at age 65.

Who knows if the Asbestos that took him came from Canada, but let's just get Production finally stopped here altogether.

Let the Feds put our Tax dollars towards helping the 200 persons finding full-time alternative work. If we can waste Billions on so many other ridiculous Government Projects like the Gun Registry, I am sure a few more million to help these folks will sit well wih Canadians if it means eliminating a substance that gives Canada a negative image to the rest of the civilized World.

Come on Ottawa, do the right thing.

The David Suzuki Foundation does not necessarily endorse the comments or views posted within this forum. All contributors acknowledge DSF's right to remove product/service endorsements and refuse publication of comments deemed to be offensive or that contravene our operating principles as a charitable organization. Please note that all comments are pre-moderated. Privacy Policy »